Website Redesign

As part of the non-profit initiative, Build-up, I collaborated on a 10 week long project to cultivate a brand identity and online experience that clearly reflected Trans Family Support Services’ mission. Our team redesigned a non-profit website that afforded better navigation and experience.
Role:
Lead UX Designer
Type:
Aspen (Director of operations)
Kathie (Founder)
Timeline:
June - Sept 2022
Team:
Sabrina Mao - UX Designer
Grace Lin - UX Researcher
Christian Flores - Web Builder
Calvin Cheung  - Web Builder
Anna Hoang - Marketing

Trans Family
Support Service

Table of Contents:

Overview

Who is Trans Family Support Services?
TransFamily Support Services is a community non-profit organization based in San Diego, California. Their mission is to provide comprehensive support and guidance to trans/nonbinary youth and their loved ones so they feel understood and personally catered towards while navigating their identity journey.

Our Goals

1.
Improve the discoverability and accessibility of their resources and services.
2.
Redesign their flagship pages for improved user engagement.
3.
Maintain a consistent, personable brand throughout the website.

Preliminary Research

With our preliminary research, we had two goals in mind: taking a closer look at the existing site and other similar sites as well as understanding the audience and their pain points. Here is how we addressed each:
01. Getting to Know the Existing Site and Other Similar Sites
We approached this by creating a site map of the current site, doing a competitive analysis of similar organizations’ websites, and conducting a web audit based on Nielsen Norman Group’s 10 usability heuristics to look for possible areas with pain points.

Current Site Map
Our team needed to understand the information architecture of the existing website first before we began researching and exploring solutions. As such, we created a site map of the existing site’s navigation.
Web Audit
Web audit of existing site based on Nielsen Norman Group’s 10 usability heuristics.
From our web audit, we found that the site relies heavily on its navigation bar, which is disorganized and complex for a new visitor. Streamlining the user flow and simplifying how content is displayed, we thought, could be an avenue for future improvements.
Annotating the existing website for strengths and possible issues (desktop site).
Annotating the existing website for strengths and possible issues (mobile site).
Competitive Analysis
With our competitive analysis, we looked for features that other competitors’ websites had in common with the TFSS website as well as aspects of their sites that we could draw inspiration from. We observed similar color palettes and having navigable links on the landing page. We also discovered unique mad lib interactions like a “fill in the blank” section for finding resources to be interesting.

Furthermore, we created a separate analysis of how competitors address (or do not address) possible pain points we observed in TFSS’s existing website.
Looking for features in common as well as unique features to draw inspiration from in competitors’ sites.
Analyzing how competitors deal with possible pain points in the TFSS website (as concluded from our web audit).

02. Understanding the Audience and their Pain Points

We met this goal by discussing with our stakeholders, distributing a user survey and conducting usability tests on the existing site, followed by affinity mapping and qualitatively analyzing the data. While chatting with the founder of TransFamily Support Services, we learned that the website, although visitable by any age group, was mostly seen by adults (especially parents of trans/nonbinary youth). This affected the direction and style we took the website later. From there, we brainstormed user personas to inform our solutions more accurately.

From the Stakeholder

In our first and subsequent meetings with the founder of TransFamily Support Services, we learned that a common theme among those the organization serves is that they all say:

“I wish I had
found you sooner.”

This revealed to us that the discoverability and accessibility of the organization’s resources are of critical importance to members and thus enabled us to act in the right direction for the redesign.

Survey
In our user survey, we got to know how people have interacted with TFSS and its services (or if they haven’t, what might motivate them to) and some first impressions of the website. To understand the results of the survey more thoroughly, we qualitatively analyzed the data by sorting them into likes, dislikes/pain points, general trends, and first impressions:
Qualitative analysis of likes, dislikes & pain points, trends, and suggestions as sorted in our spreadsheet. (Red is dislikes & pain points, green is likes, blue is trends, and yellow is suggestions for improvement.)
The first section of the survey explores how users might interact (or be motivated to interact) with the organization overall.

Affinity Mapping

But how, we asked, do these users interact with the website?
Our interviewees, who we directed to try to find various pages across the site, were previously unfamiliar with both TFSS and its website. To gather the most valuable insights from these tests, we affinity mapped the data by the particular navigation flow they addressed and identified the key points for each of the flows.

Key Insights from Our Research
Generally, first impressions of the site revealed:

User Personas

As the foundation for what we needed to improve became clearer, it was crucial for us to proceed with extensive researching and fine-tuning of our insight of the TFSS community and the overall user base. We translated the experiences of our survey respondents into possible personas, brainstorming various user groups that might be involved with TFSS:

The TFSS service is largely sought by parents/guardians with the goal of understanding how they can help their child in their transitioning journey
This user is a teen individual seeking guidance and community within the LGBTQ+ sphere.

So We Ask:

💡 How might we create a more accessible online identity for TransFamily Support Services in order to increase discoverability and provide more support for transgender and nonbinary individuals and their loved ones?

Ideation: Searching for a Solution

Brainstorming & Mind Map: How do we make information more discoverable?

The pain points narrowed down into 5 major categories: organization, overwhelming information, visual appeal, user flow/navigation, and overall content.

Then we began branching out and exploring what features a redesigned website might have to be able to address the pain points.

In addition, we quickly jotted down some words we wanted our redesign to reflect (inclusive, bright, fresh, clean, and confident) and pages that we would definitely want to keep throughout the revamp.

During a team meeting I led a rapid crazy 8s team workshop!

As we brainstormed, we realized that our ideas diverged in so many directions and we were having a hard time defining the most important and actionable ones. To visualize this, I suggested a ideation methodology called Crazy 8s to rapidly produce ideas during our 10-week sprint to redesign this website.

During our round of Crazy 8s, we each of us sat down for 8 minutes and visualized up to 8 sketches of various solutions. When we finished, we gathered our sketches and discussed them as a group, dot voting on certain concepts we wanted to move forward with.

Hmm this is hard to navigate? Let's revise the site map

As mentioned earlier, one glaring problem of the site was its disorganized and complex navigation bar. In an attempt to tackle this, we created another site map with reorganized pages to address the information architecture.

After consolidation with our stakeholders, we decided to scrap their current navigation system altogether in favor of one that is slightly more organized, although heavy on the resources tab.
After one more round of validation from stakeholders, we decided to add a services tab to lessen the amount of options on the resources tab and allow users to differentiate between services the organization offers and resources they provide. This led to the final form of the site’s information architecture.

Design: The Road to High Fidelity

From whiteboard sketches to Figma!

To improve a better understanding of the TFSS services and foster a smoother navigation process, I sketched and drafted wireframes that presented the navigation information at the top of the website with a more extensive landing page layout. We explored successful tools from other nonprofits in our competitive analysis such as a user-focused toggle mad libs section, featured resource cards, testimonials and overall visually engaging content.

Creating a more captivating and welcoming visual design

Based on our branding ideation session with our stakeholders, we were able to cultivate a better understanding of the Trans Family Support Services’ brand: Navigation for the Journey. Given that the nonprofit’s main audience consists of families of trans individuals, it called for a more mature and inviting tone for design. More than half of users in initial usability tests also stated that their impression of the original landing page was “barren”, “bland”, and had “too much white space”. This led us to utilizing pastel colors in the palette and softer gradients of those colors to help emphasize a more visually engaging impression.

We contrasted softer colors with bolder cool colors such as the Navy and Azure to better gain accessibility visually. We also worked to incorporate a wave theme throughout as a way to tie the idea of navigation with a sense of serene guidance.

High Fidelity Screens

Final Prototype Changes

Clearer Content Design
with Hero Header

We incorporated a standardized header to better inform users about TFSS and what they do as a nonprofit. Most interviewees struggled to find the about page and “mostly agreed” that the original navigation of the about page was “difficult to find”. To reduce difficulty in learning about the nonprofit, we decided to present the content as a mission statement in the hero header.

Personalized Reviews
with Testimonials

There was expressed concern from users wanting to “know more about people’s experiences” hence the addition of the “What families/people say about us” testimonials section on the landing page. By incorporating more individualized content, we were able to build a more user-friendly website and bring forth a better sense of community that was hidden within the original website.

Content Organization
with a Gallery View
To improve readability, we organized a more comprehensive structure to the former layout of information. We helped fix formatting and integrated a grid foundation for the website content to continue mitigating navigation issues and inconsistencies.

Improving Accessibility and Discoverability with Top-down Navigation Bar
Over half of users mainly struggled with the task of finding the about us page, blog page, and insurance/medical assistance. By switching the navigation bar from the side to  top-down, we were able to get rid of navigation ambiguity that most users encountered with the previous website. By condensing several resources that fell under the same umbrella categories, we were able to mitigate the traffic of information that users found overwhelming in the search process.

Making additional support for finding services with a Mad Libs Section
A critical point and goal from our stakeholders was to help facilitate a better way to get resources as accessible and easy for families, medical professionals, trans youth/individuals, etc. We incorporated a mad libs section that allows the user to select their identity and select what they are interested in. This tool was taken inspiration from another nonprofit in the competitive analysis and essentially utilizes a toggle down button followed with an extension to specific links to resources.

Usability Testing: Have We Met Users’ Needs?

After our final prototyping, our users say that the redesign looks more clean, intuitive and straightforward, and inviting. This validated our design objectives as well as efforts to address user paint points with the old website, such as the unclear organization of content, bland design, and overall personality of the previous website.

Overall improvements

Creating more impact with a wore wisually stunning Landing Page

We believed that the new landing page should offer a greater breadth of resources than the older iteration. This is due to the fact that it is the most impactful page in making a first impression on the user. We included photos captured by the organization’s photographer to make way for a more personable landing page. Additionally, we created mad libs to help users identify their purpose on the site in an effort to personalize their experience.

Before

Final

Reducing overloading the user with consistent CTAs for the What We Do page

From our usability tests, a major pain point expressed by our users was the overwhelming amount of options in the what we do section of the navigation bar. This led to users being unable to decide which page to visit first and made it difficult to find a specific page. To tackle this, we revamped the What We Do page to provide a better overview of services and made use of CTAs to avoid overwhelming with information at one glance.

Before

Final

Better representing the community with a section navigation menu for the Who We Are page

The older iteration makes use of testimonials and box messages to give a gist of the team behind TransFamily Support Services. We wanted to redesign this page by showing headshots of the entire group of wonderful people that dedicate their time to this cause. In this manner, the average user is able to immediately familiarize with everyone involved in the nonprofit organization.

Before

Final

How We Met Our Goals

1.
With our more intuitive information architecture and navigation flow, approachable ‘mad libs’ fill-in section, and clearer content, users can now access important info and resources more easily.
2.
Content has become less overwhelming in style and amount, and call-to-action elements like buttons are much clearer; these invite the user to explore the pages more.
3.
By creating and adhering to a design system that represents the brand of the organization, the website now features a more coherent visual identity that creates a unique impression on viewers.

What we learned

Communication is Key

Whether it be with stakeholders or other group members, communication and trust with every step of the way led to efficient and effective progress.
Design is a Bumpy Road

The process of creating beautiful experiences is anything but beautiful. Embrace the chaos and try jumping at every opportunity to improve.
Deadlines are Crucial

Setting dates for when we wanted to have deliverables finished held group members accountable and ensured we progressed (even if it was all mostly done the night before).
Get Feedback

Our end product was greatly improved thanks to feedback from our mentors (Tarrea, Alex, & Chy), our TFSS point of contact (Aspen), and other builders.

Next Steps

In the future, possible ways we can envision expanding on this project include:

  1. Continue planning and improving A/B components for testing.
  2. Including more usability tests for the final round of validation! Due to the rapid nature of the program, our team was only able to receive 3 usability testing.
  3. Continue working with developers to implement any remaining website pages and designs!

A Big Thank You To…

Thank you for reading this case study! Check out my other work!

Mobile Tree Map
Mobile Design